Acts and Regulations

E-10.5 - Essential Services in Nursing Homes Act

Full text
Current to 1 January 2024
CHAPTER E-10.5
Essential Services in Nursing Homes Act
Assented to May 1, 2009
Her Majesty, by and with the advice and consent of the Legislative Assembly of New Brunswick, enacts as follows:
Definitions
1The following definitions apply in this Act.
“Board” means the Labour and Employment Board established under the Labour and Employment Board Act.(Commission)
“employer” means an operator as defined in the Nursing Homes Act.(employeur)
“essential services” means services that, if interrupted, would endanger the life, personal safety or health of one or more of the residents of a nursing home.(services essentiels)
2019, c.34, s.1
Interpretation
2Unless otherwise provided, words and expressions used in this Act have the same meaning as in the Industrial Relations Act.
Application
3This Act applies to operators of nursing homes, as employers, and to the employees of nursing homes for whom bargaining agents have been certified under the Industrial Relations Act.
2019, c.34, s.2
Conflict
4If there is a conflict between this Act and the Industrial Relations Act, this Act prevails.
Request for designation
5(1)In relation to a bargaining unit, an employer may, by notice in writing, advise the Board and the bargaining agent for the relevant bargaining unit that the employer considers in whole or in part the services provided by the bargaining unit to be essential services.
5(2)A notice may be given
(a) in respect of a bargaining unit for which a bargaining agent is certified at the commencement of this section,
(i) if no collective agreement or arbitral award is in force, at any time until a collective agreement is concluded or arbitral award is rendered, or
(ii) if a collective agreement or arbitral award is in force, at any time during the term of the collective agreement or arbitral award except within the last 6 months before the agreement or award ceases to operate, or
(b) in respect of a bargaining unit for which a bargaining agent is certified after the commencement of this section,
(i) if no collective agreement or arbitral award is in force, within 20 days after the date of certification of the bargaining agent, or
(ii) if a collective agreement or arbitral award is in force, at any time during the term of the collective agreement or arbitral award except within the last 6 months before the agreement or award ceases to operate.
2019, c.34, s.3
Essential services agreements
2019, c.34, s.4
6(1)Within seven days after receiving a notice referred to in section 5, the Board shall, in consultation with the employer and the bargaining agent, establish time limits within which the employer and the bargaining agent shall endeavour to reach an essential services agreement.
6(2)An essential services agreement shall
(a) identify the essential services that are provided by the bargaining unit that need to be maintained during a strike or a lock-out,
(b) identify the level of service to be maintained by the bargaining unit to provide the essential services referred to in paragraph (a),
(c) identify the positions in the bargaining unit as designated positions for the purpose of providing the essential services referred to in paragraph (a), and
(d) set out the procedures to be followed in responding to emergencies and foreseeable changes to the essential services referred to in paragraph (a).
6(3)In endeavouring to reach an essential services agreement, the employer and bargaining agent are required to consider only the needs of the residents of the nursing home in which the employees in the bargaining unit are employed and may not adopt by reference, in whole or in part, an essential services agreement reached by another bargaining unit.
2019, c.34, s.5
Requirements for negotiating an essential services agreement
2019, c.34, s.6
6.1(1)An employer and a bargaining agent shall negotiate in good faith and make every reasonable effort to reach an essential services agreement within the time limits established by the Board under subsection 6(1).
6.1(2)At any time during negotiations to reach an essential services agreement, an employer or bargaining agent may make a complaint in writing to the Board that the other party has failed to comply with subsection (1), and the Board shall inquire into the complaint.
6.1(3)The time limits for reaching an essential services agreement cease to run from the date the Board receives a complaint until the Board completes its inquiry into the complaint.
6.1(4)If the Board is satisfied after an inquiry that a party has failed to comply with subsection (1), the Board may do any of the following:
(a) issue an order directing the party to comply; or
(b) issue any other order it considers appropriate.
2019, c.34, s.6
Mediation to assist in reaching an essential services agreement
2019, c.34, s.6
6.2(1)If an employer and a bargaining agent are unable to reach an essential services agreement, the Board shall appoint a mediator to assist the parties in reaching the agreement.
6.2(2)The employer and the bargaining agent shall each promptly give the mediator a statement setting out the matters on which the parties have agreed, if any, and the matters on which they are unable to agree.
6.2(3)As soon as the circumstances permit after giving the mediator the statements referred to in subsection (2), the employer and the bargaining agent shall meet with the mediator to endeavour to reach an essential services agreement.
6.2(4)Within the time limit established by the Board, or any longer period agreed on by the parties, the mediator shall provide the Board with a report stating that the parties have reached an essential services agreement, or, if an agreement has not been reached, setting out the matters on which the parties have agreed and setting out the matters on which the parties are unable to agree.
6.2(5)If the employer and the bargaining agent reach an essential services agreement with the assistance of the mediator, they shall communicate the essential services agreement to the Board in accordance with section 7.
6.2(6)If the employer and the bargaining agent do not reach an essential services agreement with the assistance of the mediator, the Board shall act under section 8.
6.2(7)The employer and the bargaining agent shall bear their own costs of the mediation and shall equally share all other costs of the mediation, unless otherwise agreed by them.
2019, c.34, s.6
Essential services agreement reached by the parties
2019, c.34, s.7
7If an employer and a bargaining agent are able to reach an essential services agreement within the time limits established under subsection 6(1), the terms of the agreement shall be jointly communicated by the parties to the Board and the Board shall issue an order without delay in accordance with those terms.
2019, c.34, s.8
Essential services agreement not reached by the parties
2019, c.34, s.9
8(1)If an employer and a bargaining agent are unable to reach an essential services agreement with the assistance of a mediator under section 6.2, the Board, after giving each of the parties an opportunity to present evidence and to make representations, shall issue an order that complies with the requirements of subsections 6(2) and (3).
8(2)The Board shall provide a copy of the order to the employer and the bargaining agent as soon as the circumstances permit after issuing an order under subsection (1).
2019, c.34, s.10
Amendments to orders
2019, c.34, s.11
9(1)The Board may, on the application of the employer or the bargaining agent for the relevant bargaining unit made within the time limits established in subsection (2), amend an order issued under section 7 or 8.
9(2)An application may be made
(a) when a collective agreement or arbitral award is in force, at any time, or
(b) when a collective agreement or arbitral award is not in force, at any time before the appointment of a conciliation officer, conciliation board, mediator or mediation officer under the Industrial Relations Act, whichever occurs first.
9(3)If the employer and the bargaining agent agree on the amendments to be made, the terms of the agreement shall be jointly communicated by the parties to the Board and the Board shall issue an amended order without delay in accordance with those terms.
9(4)If the employer and the bargaining agent are unable to reach agreement, the Board, after giving each of the parties an opportunity to present evidence and to make representations, shall issue an amended order that complies with the requirements of subsections 6(2) and (3) and shall provide a copy of the order to the employer and the bargaining agent as soon as the circumstances permit after issuing the order.
2019, c.34, s.12
Effect of order
10(1)An order issued by the Board under section 7, 8, 9 or 13.1 binds the employer and the bargaining agent as well as the employees affected by the order.
10(2)An order issued by the Board under section 7 or 8 remains in effect unless amended by the Board under section 9.
2019, c.34, s.13
Communication of order to employees
2019, c.34, s.14
11The Board shall inform all employees in a bargaining unit who are employed in positions that are identified as designated positions in an order issued under section 7, 8 or 9 of the order within the time and in the manner that the Board determines.
2019, c.34, s.15
Illegal activities
12(1)If a notice referred to in section 5 is given by an employer or an application referred to in section 9 is made by an employer or a bargaining agent, no employee in the bargaining unit in respect of which the notice was given or the application was made shall strike or participate in a strike until
(a) an order has been issued under section 7, 8 or 9 that identifies the designated positions in the bargaining unit and the employees in those positions have been informed by the Board;
(b) at least seven days have elapsed after the bargaining agent for the employee’s bargaining unit informs the Board in writing of its intention to strike; and
(c) any applicable requirements of the Industrial Relations Act have been satisfied.
12(2)No employee who is employed in a designated position shall participate in a strike.
12(3)No trade union or council of trade unions and no officer, director, representative, employee, agent or advisor of the trade union or council of trade unions shall declare, authorize, continue or counsel a strike of employees in contravention of subsection (1) or (2).
12(3.1)If a notice referred to in section 5 is given by an employer or an application referred to in section 9 is made by an employer or a bargaining agent, no employer and no officer, director, representative, employee, agent or advisor of the employer shall lock-out employees in the bargaining unit in respect of which the notice was given or the application was made until
(a) an order has been issued under section 7, 8 or 9 that identifies the designated positions in the bargaining unit and the employees in those positions have been informed by the Board;
(b) at least seven days have elapsed after the employer informs the Board in writing of its intention to lock-out those employees; and
(c) any applicable requirements of the Industrial Relations Act have been satisfied.
12(4)No employer and no officer, director, representative, employee, agent or advisor of the employer shall lock-out employees who are employed in designated positions or declare, authorize, continue or counsel a lock-out of those employees.
12(5)If the employees of a nursing home are engaged in a legal strike under the Industrial Relations Act, the following prohibitions apply for the duration of the strike:
(a) no employee shall picket, parade or in any manner demonstrate in or near any place of business of the employer;
(b) no trade union or council of trade unions and no officer, director, representative, employee, agent or advisor of the trade union or council of trade unions shall declare, authorize, continue or counsel picketing, a parade or any manner of demonstration in contravention of paragraph (a); and
(c) no employer shall replace the striking employees or fill their positions with any other employees.
2011, c.29, s.1; 2019, c.34, s.16
Extension of the collective agreement
13(1)Even though the term of a collective agreement or arbitral award last in force between an employer and a bargaining agent for the relevant bargaining unit has expired, the terms and conditions of employment contained in the agreement or award remain in force after the expiration of the agreement or award and apply in relation to
(a) an employee in the bargaining unit employed in a designated position who is required to work during a strike or a lock-out, or
(b) all the employees in the bargaining unit, if an order providing for binding arbitration as a dispute mechanism is issued under subsection 13.1(5).
13(2)An employee employed in a designated position shall not, during a strike or a lock-out, be required to work more hours, including overtime, than the employee would have been required to work had the strike or lock-out not occurred.
2019, c.34, s.17
Meaningful process for collective bargaining
2019, c.34, s.18
13.1(1)If a bargaining agent or an employer that is bound by an order issued under section 8 or subsection 9(4) considers that the level of service to be maintained by the bargaining unit to provide essential services has the effect of substantially interfering with a meaningful collective bargaining process, the bargaining agent or employer, as the case may be, may apply to the Board for an order providing for binding arbitration as a dispute mechanism between the parties.
13.1(2)An application referred to in subsection (1) shall be made by written notice to the Board and to the other party within 30 days after the date the Board provides the employer and the bargaining agent a copy of the order issued under section 8 or subsection 9(4), as the case may be.
13.1(3)On receiving an application under subsection (1), the Board shall hear the matter as soon as the circumstances permit and shall issue an order with reasons setting out how it considered the factors in subsection (4).
13.1(4)In determining an application under subsection (1), the Board shall consider
(a) the level of service to be maintained by the bargaining unit to provide the essential services identified in the order,
(b) the positions in the bargaining unit that have been identified as designated positions for the purpose of providing the essential services referred to in paragraph (a), and
(c) any other factor the Board considers relevant.
13.1(5)If the Board determines that the level of service to be maintained by the bargaining unit to provide essential services has the effect of depriving the parties of a meaningful collective bargaining process, the Board shall issue an order that if, after bargaining collectively, the parties fail to conclude a collective agreement or the renewal or revision of an existing collective agreement, all matters remaining in dispute between them shall be settled by binding arbitration in accordance with the Industrial Relations Act and section 13.3.
2019, c.34, s.18
Prohibited activities
2019, c.34, s.18
13.2(1)If the Board issues an order providing for binding arbitration as a dispute mechanism under subsection 13.1(5), no employee in the bargaining unit in respect of which the order was issued shall strike or participate in a strike.
13.2(2)No trade union or council of trade unions and no officer, director, representative, employee, agent or advisor of a trade union or council of trade unions shall declare, authorize, continue or counsel a strike of employees in contravention of subsection (1).
13.2(3)If the Board issues an order providing for binding arbitration as a dispute mechanism under subsection 13.1(5), no employer and no officer, director, representative, employee, agent or advisor of an employer shall lock-out employees in the bargaining unit in respect of which the order was issued.
13.2(4)No employer and no officer, director, representative, employee, agent or advisor of an employer shall declare, authorize, continue or counsel a lock-out of employees in contravention of subsection (3).
2019, c.34, s.18
Mediation and binding arbitration
2019, c.34, s.18
13.3(1)If an employer and a bargaining agent that are bound by an order under subsection 13.1(5), after bargaining collectively, fail to conclude a collective agreement or the renewal or revision of an existing collective agreement, they are required to request that the Minister of Post-Secondary Education, Training and Labour appoint a mediator under section 70 of the Industrial Relations Act to assist them, and the Minister shall appoint a mediator.
13.3(2)If the employer and the bargaining agent fail to conclude a collective agreement or the renewal or revision of an existing collective agreement with the assistance of the mediator, either of the parties may request that the Board refer all matters remaining in dispute between them to binding arbitration in accordance with the order under subsection 13.1(5).
13.3(3)The Board shall refer all matters remaining in dispute between the parties to binding arbitration in accordance with the Industrial Relations Act if it is satisfied that collective bargaining has been carried out in good faith, including the collective bargaining with the assistance of the mediator referred to in subsection (1), but it considers that it is unlikely that the parties will agree, within a reasonable time, on the conclusion of a collective agreement or to the renewal or revision of an existing collective agreement.
13.3(4)In rendering an arbitral award, an arbitrator shall take into consideration the following factors, and any other factors that the arbitrator considers relevant, for the period in which the arbitral award will apply:
(a) as the primary factor, the wages negotiated through collective bargaining between the Province and public sector employees performing the same or similar functions in the same or similar circumstances as the employees in the bargaining unit, considering the entire compensation package including, but not limited to, retirement plans or pensions, medical and dental benefits, life insurance and disability insurance, shift premiums, bonuses and paid time off;
(b) as the secondary factor, the wages of other unionized private sector employees in New Brunswick and non-unionized private sector employees in New Brunswick performing the same or similar functions in the same or similar circumstances as the employees in the bargaining unit, considering the entire compensation package including, but not limited to, retirement plans or pensions, medical and dental benefits, life insurance and disability insurance, shift premiums, bonuses and paid time off; and
(c) as additional factors: 
(i) the employer’s ability to pay, in light of the fiscal situation of the Province, and
(ii) the need to maintain appropriate relationships in terms and conditions of employment between grade levels within an occupation and between occupations in nursing homes.
13.3(5)In the arbitral award, the arbitrator shall include written reasons that explain how the arbitrator has considered the factors in subsection (4).
2019, c.34, s.18
Offences
14(1)Every person who violates or fails to comply with subsection 12(1) or (2) or paragraph 12(5)(a) or subsection 13.2(1) commits an offence and is liable on conviction to a fine not exceeding $100 per day or part of a day during which the offence continues.
14(2)Every person who violates or fails to comply with subsection 12(3) or 13.2(2) commits an offence and is liable on conviction,
(a) in the case of an offence committed by a trade union or council of trade unions, to a fine of $10 per employee in the relevant bargaining unit for each day or part of a day for which the strike declared, authorized, continued or counselled in contravention of that subsection is or continues in effect, or to a fine of $10,000, whichever is greater, or
(b) in the case of an offence committed by an officer, director, representative, employee, agent or advisor of a trade union or council of trade unions, to a fine not exceeding $300 for each day or part of a day for which the strike declared, authorized, continued or counselled in contravention of that subsection is or continues in effect.
14(3)Every person who violates or fails to comply with subsection 12(3.1) or (4) or 13.2(3) or (4) commits an offence and is liable on conviction to a fine not exceeding $300 for each day or part of a day for which the lock-out is imposed, declared, authorized, continued or counselled in contravention of either of those subsections.
14(4)Every person who violates or fails to comply with paragraph 12(5)(b) commits an offence and is liable on conviction,
(a) in the case of an offence committed by a trade union or council of trade unions, to a fine of $10 per employee in the relevant bargaining unit for each day or part of a day for which the picketing, parade or demonstration declared, authorized, continued or counselled in contravention of that paragraph is or continues in effect, or to a fine of $10,000, whichever is greater; or
(b) in the case of an offence committed by an officer, director, representative, employee, agent or advisor of a trade union or council of trade unions, to a fine not exceeding $300 for each day or part of a day for which the picketing, parade or demonstration declared, authorized, continued or counselled in contravention of that paragraph is or continues in effect.
14(5)Every person who violates or fails to comply with paragraph 12(5)(c) commits an offence and is liable on conviction to a fine not exceeding $300 for each day or part of a day for which one or more employees replace striking employees in contravention of that paragraph.
2011, c.29, s.2; 2019, c.34, s.19
Revocation of certification
15In addition to any other penalty provided in section 14, on the application of an employer, the Board may revoke the certification of a bargaining agent if a trade union or council of trade unions, or any officer, director, representative, employee, agent or advisor of a trade union or counsel of trade unions, as the case may be, has been found guilty of violating or failing to comply with subsection 12(3), paragraph 12(5)(b), or subsection 13.2(2).
2019, c.34, s.20
Application of Industrial Relations Act
16 For the purposes of this Act, sections 112, 113, 121, 124, paragraph 125(1)(h), subsections 125(2) to (5) and 126(1), paragraphs 126(2)(j) and (k), section 127, subsections 128(1) and (3), sections 130 and 131, subsections 132(2) and 134(3), section 135, subsections 136(1) to (4), 137(1) and 138(2) and sections 140 and 141 of the Industrial Relations Act apply with the necessary modifications.
Disclosure of information
2019, c.34, s.21
16.1(1)No information or material provided to or received by a mediator under section 6.2 shall be disclosed except to the Board.
16.1(2)No report of a mediator under section 6.2 shall be disclosed except to the Board and the parties.
16.1(3)A mediator appointed under section 6.2 is not a competent or compellable witness in proceedings before any court or other tribunal respecting any information, material or report mentioned in subsection (1) or (2) or respecting any information or material provided to or received by the mediator, or any statement made to or by the mediator in an endeavour to assist the parties reach an essential services agreement.
2019, c.34, s.21
Administration of Act
17 The Minister of Social Development shall administer this Act.
2016, c.37, s.63; 2019, c.2, s.50
Regulations
18The Board may make regulations
(a) establishing rules of procedure in respect of hearings held under sections 8, 9, and 13.1;
(b) prescribing the manner in which and the time within which the employer shall, in respect of a bargaining unit, provide to the Board the names of the employees in the bargaining unit who are employed in designated positions;
(c) respecting the specification of the time within which and the persons to whom notices and other documents are to be sent and when such notices are deemed to have been given and received; and
(d) respecting such other matters and things as may be incidental or conducive to the objects and purposes of the Board, the exercise of its powers and the attainment of the objects of this Act.
2011, c.29, s.3; 2019, c.34, s.22
Consequential amendment to the Labour and Employment Board Act
19Subsection 7(2) of the Labour and Employment Board Act, chapter L-0.01 of the Acts of New Brunswick, 1994, is amended by adding after paragraph (b) the following:
(b.1) Essential Services in Nursing Homes Act,
N.B. This Act is consolidated to December 20, 2019.